4 Hidden Dangers of a ‘Scarcity Mindset’ That Keep You From Decluttering
Inside: Learn how having a ‘scarcity mindset’ keeps you from decluttering and how you can change it.
As many of us pursue a simpler, more organized life, decluttering is a key step to achieving our goals.
But for many people, the process of letting go of possessions and creating space can be unexpectedly challenging.
This difficulty often stems from what psychologists refer to as a ‘scarcity mindset’—a pervasive belief that resources, opportunities, and even personal worth are limited.
This mindset can contribute to clutter in a big way – and create a barrier to some who try to embrace a simpler lifestyle.
Not sure if you’re struggling with a scarcity mindset – or how to overcome the challenge? Keep reading to see how this mindset hinders the decluttering process and learn some tips to overcome it.
What causes a scarcity mindset?
When you’re dealing with a scarcity mindset, you experience a lot of stress, anxiety, and fear about not having enough in the future – but the source of the problem is often rooted in the past.
Scarcity mindsets can take hold for a number of reasons, but in many cases, it’s the result of a loss, trauma, or going through a period of time when you felt as though you didn’t have enough.
It might be caused by losing a job, a home, or a relationship. Many who grow up in poverty are left with a scarcity mindset, even after they’ve achieved financial security and stability.
Similar to grandparents who grew up during the Great Depression, for those who experienced a lack it can become more challenging to learn to let go.
If you fear that things cannot be replaced or that you may not have the resources you need, it creates a great deal of anxiety and stress.
How can a scarcity mindset keep you from decluttering?
Not only can a scarcity mindset contribute to clutter, but it can also cripple you in the process of trying to fix the problem.
Decluttering isn’t an easy task for anyone – but when you add in the complexities a scarcity mindset can bring, it makes it even more challenging.
Here are just a few ways a scarcity mindset can keep you from decluttering:
1. You see decluttering as wasting money.
When you’re struggling with a scarcity mindset, thoughts about not having enough aren’t strictly limited to physical possessions. You may feel the same about money. You can’t have enough of it to feel truly secure, and you can’t stand the thought of throwing away your hard-earned cash.
At that point, you don’t see clutter for what it is – stuff that’s taking up space and adding no value to your life. Instead, you view it through the context of the money you spent on it.
One of the reasons people hold onto clutter is because they feel like they’re throwing away money, which can cause additional feelings of guilt and regret.
The good news is there are frugal ways to declutter that can help you save money while letting go of the extra things you don’t need.
2. You hold onto things “just in case.”
Another hallmark of the scarcity mindset is wanting to keep things around with the justification of “just in case.”
You hold onto old cords and cables, books you’ll never read again, electronics you’ve upgraded a long time ago on the off chance something will happen and they’ll be of use again.
In reality, the chances you actually need those things are low – and you could always replace them if the need did arise. But when you’re stuck in a scarcity mindset, that isn’t a guarantee.
A scarcity mindset can also feed into your fears about the future and the potential of various possibilities. You may fear that you’ll regret letting go of these items that could be useful in some scenarios.
However, that thinking doesn’t consider how all those things you’re desperately holding onto now are impacting you in the present. Keeping excessive items carries daily stress and burdens with them and that is guaranteed.
3. You develop irrational emotional attachments to physical possessions.
When living with a scarcity mindset, your possessions aren’t just things. They can become your security blanket and items that may not even be useful can give you a false sense of preparedness.
It’s also possible for them to become symbols of your success, reminders of significant events, or tokens of affection from those you love. They represent your self-worth and offer a sense of belonging.
And when your emotions and identity begin to intertwine with your stuff, the thought of getting rid of it becomes even harder – making the act of decluttering nearly impossible.
This is when it’s important to remember that you are not your stuff. No one is. Your value is far more than any tangible item and you deserve to be free of the burdens that are weighing you down.
4. You keep adding to the stuff in your home, increasing your clutter.
When you have a scarcity mindset, one strategy for coping and mitigating stress involves acquiring as much as possible – forever expanding the assortment of stuff in your home.
With possessions accumulating faster than you can get rid of them, clutter continues to grow and expand, presenting even more of a problem.
Check to see if you’re experiencing some of the signs that you have too much stuff. Often the goal with holding onto things is imagining that you’ll want them at some point, but if your home is overstuffed it’s unlikely you’d be able to easily locate them anyway.
Additionally storing extra stuff on the very small chance you might use it keeps someone else from being able to enjoy it now. It can also leave an unnecessary burden on your spouse or children to have to sort through later.
How can you overcome a scarcity mindset and declutter your home?
A scarcity mindset can certainly present a challenge, but it isn’t insurmountable.
By acting with intention and taking meaningful steps to mitigate the problem, you can shift away from feelings of scarcity. And, in the process, make your home more manageable.
1. Shift your mindset to one of abundance.
The opposite of a scarcity mindset is an abundance mindset. While it might be hard to see the world through a drastically different lens, it is possible. It just takes a little bit of intentional effort.
By focusing on gratitude for the things you do have, and realizing that you have everything you need (and more), you can begin to let go of limiting beliefs and shake off that scarcity mindset.
You can then shift your thinking to get into a decluttering mindset as you let go of the excess stuff.
2. Take it one step at a time.
You won’t be decluttering your whole house in a weekend with a scarcity mindset – and that’s okay.
For 1 in 3 people, it takes a week or longer to complete a decluttering project. And that’s ok. After all, it took a while to accumulate the clutter and it’s a process to work through letting it go.
Using the slow declutter method is preferred by the vast majority of people anyway. It creates less stress and makes the decluttering process feel more doable.
Focus on breaking the task up into manageable segments. That might mean starting as small as getting rid of a single item each day. Another option is tackling a very defined area of your home – such as a drawer or shelf.
Start with a couple of these 10-minute decluttering tasks that will have big results in your home. This will help jumpstart the process so that you can begin making progress right away.
3. Set goals – and stay focused on them.
Before you begin, understand what you want to achieve. Define your decluttering goals – and put some real thought into them.
Think about the why – the driving force behind your actions.
Do you want to be able to invite friends and family over and feel proud to show them around your space? Or do you want to be able to relax in the evenings in a clean, relaxing environment?
Maybe you just want to be able to find all the stuff that you’ve lost among the clutter in your house. Or perhaps you don’t want to leave all the things you’ve been keeping for your kids to have to deal with later.
Whatever your reasons, set realistic goals for your home, and once you’re clear on what they are, write them down. Put them in a visible place that you can revisit as often as you need to. Make them the background of your phone, or write them on sticky notes and put them on your fridge.
Reminding yourself of the desired end result will help keep you motivated and make you less likely to give into a scarcity mindset.
Are you facing a scarcity mindset that’s keeping you from decluttering? Let us know in the comments section if you realize this is what’s been holding you back.
Sign up on the form below to get weekly decluttering tips and inspiration sent straight to your inbox. You’ll also get the free 5 Areas to Declutter in 10 Minutes Checklist to help you get started decluttering today.
I have now identified this ….AS ME to a ” T “
Knowing that is your struggle is the first step to overcoming it!
You can blame media for part of this. They frequently show empty shelves in stores that indicate a shortage looming. (Ie. Covid toilet paper shortage.). And disasters.
We do need emergency food, water, first aid, clothing, meds, that alone is over wheming. It’s hard to know where to draw the line.
That’s a good point, Darleen. Media and social media do play a role as people can quickly get into a fear mindset based on perceived scarcity. The recent run on toilet paper due to the port issues was an example of that (which is particularly interesting since that isn’t an oversees product).
I am a hoarder, I do understand why I can’t let go of ‘stuff’ (sentimental & what I might use later). I started declutterring, however, my declutterring of my home is currently on hold as I am currently clearing out my deceased parents property. It’s emotional & physically hard, but it has helped me in that I am DETERMINED to declutter my home so I can enjoy a declutterred home & keep minimal items & know that I am not leaving my clutter for my children to dispose off.
One step at a time, Anne. You’ll get there. Take good care of yourself.
My problem is clothes! My love of clothes, but the problem is I tend to hold on to clothes that have been gifted to me out of guilt! How can I get past the guilt of gifted clothing and let it go!?
Deb,
I had the same problem years ago. Then I changed my mindset to donate the items so someone else could love them. Some of the items I never even got to wear! It was very liberating to let go and very satisfying to know someone else would enjoy them. Good luck!
Hi Deb. It helps me to think of it from the reverse perspective. If I gifted someone clothes that either didn’t fit them or they didn’t love would I want them keeping them out of guilt? My answer is definitely not so that makes it easier for me to let them go guilt free. Hanging onto them when you aren’t wearing them doesn’t do anyone any good so if you think of it as allowing someone else who will use it to have it instead that can make it easier.
One of the things I learned from minimalist Dacy Gillespie, personal stylist, is that the joy was in the giving. We are not obligated to keep things given to us that we have no use for. That you received a gift given to you in kindness provided joy to the giver. Now you are free to let the item go. Dacy advocates donating items so that they fall into the hands of someone who loves them. In that way, you, too, have given joy.
I’m totally dealing with scarcity mentality. As a kid my family had barely enough to get by, my dad passed when I was 20 and I saw my mom in poverty, which I began taking care of her in my 30’s to help her. Then I also was divorced and scraping by in mid 20’s and 30’s. Then remarried all was well until cancer hit 2018 then COVID … I gained then lost a bunch of weight and still have all the clothes! All sizes. I try resell in Poshmark and Mercari… cheap too. But no one is buying anymore. Don’t want to throw away… $$. I’m trying to declutter. It’s hard.
Thanks for sharing, Sandra. Have you considered donating the clothes? Even though you won’t get money back it feels better to give them to a person or place that can use them rather than throwing them out.
If you have business attire that no longer fits, Dress for Success is a marvelous place to donate. DFS aids women with little means dress as they return to the workforce. They are located in most metropolitan areas. Perhaps there’s one near you.
I have everything building up around me just anything even up at the back door the living room and dining room and the kitchen is bad I know I have issues but it’s so hard because I come up with all those things to not get rid BUT I do know I’ve got to sooner or later I am suppose to be moving house at some point BY my landlord he doesn’t know how bad it is Because I don’t let him in I wait outside for him to pay the rent the problem only comes up if he wants the boiler man or something doing else then I avoid phone calls etc see the issue is it all makes me feel secure and safe so yeah I have a huge problem I also have high anxiety stress and depression so not good at all