There are different ways to approach decluttering. Some people are extreme and others more moderate. I practice frugal decluttering. Here is what that means.

How Frugal Decluttering Is Different:

People who choose to declutter frugally desire to live a simpler life and also have a strong desire to save money. Trying to balance simplicity and frugality can be a challenge, but frugal decluttering works to do both.

Frugal declutterers are more concerned about finances and trying to save or make money when possible. Some of the choices frugal declutterers make about what to keep and what to get rid of are different.

How to Practice Frugal Decluttering

To do frugal decluttering in your home, it may take a bit more time and effort. Here are some things to think through and some tips to help.

Questions to ask when decluttering

Following Marie Kondo, many people ask if their items spark joy when they are decluttering their home. If you want to declutter more frugally, your focus isn’t solely on how much you do or don’t like everything you own.

Being able to declutter at all is a privilege because it means you have excess. People who have tighter budgets may not feel as free to get rid of everything they don’t love.

While you want to keep what is beautiful, you also keep what is useful. To declutter frugally means focusing more on use and function rather than having the ideal version of all the things you own.

You might buy nicer things in the future if it’s in the budget, but there isn’t a rush to have the best of everything or to get rid of things that are perfectly functional.

These decluttering questions can help you make decisions but when you are trying to get rid of the excess as well as save money, your perspective may be a bit different.

Evaluating what you keep

When you declutter frugally you are not getting rid of functional items you know you would have to replace immediately. Frugal declutterers are more likely to get hung up on keeping clutter because they think it may be useful at some point.

The 20/20 rule

Frugal declutterers may not be as extreme due to their desire to save money and not have to repurchase items.

People who declutter this way don’t follow the 20/20 rule of it you can replace it in 20 minutes or less for 20 dollars or less, it goes. Twenty dollars to a frugal person is a lot.

My tendency toward frugal decluttering is an aspect of why I focus on simplicity, not minimalism. Frugality is part of what keeps me from getting more extreme with simplifying. There are frugal declutterers who are minimalists. That just isn’t where I am in my journey.

Duplicates

When you choose frugal decluttering, you don’t feel the need to get rid of all duplicates. You may keep a backup of certain items should something break or get ruined.

When you already own the backup, you know you don’t have to go buy a replacement right away. Frugal declutterers find security in that and don’t feel the need to eradicate every duplicate item from their home.

In our home, we have duplicates of many office supplies so we backups when the paper or pens run out.

I also opted not to get rid of jeans that fit that I liked when I decluttered my closet. That way when a pair got worn out or stained, it isn’t a big deal. I already had replacement pairs.

That doesn’t mean frugal declutterers keep every duplicate item, but they are ok with not getting rid of all back of supplies. They want to make use of what they have on hand if that saves them from some repurchasing in the future.

Along those same lines, they’re more inclined to store items for the future that they think will be used again, such as saving clothes for siblings.

frugal decluttering

Repurposing items

When you practice frugal decluttering, you may also try upcycling or repurposing items. It’s particularly attractive when it can save or make you money.

If you enjoy upcycling, there are a myriad of projects you can find on Pinterest. If you have extra coffee mugs you can upcycle them into planters like in the picture at the top of this post. You can find a tutorial for that here.

The danger for people who enjoy this kind of thing can be thinking EVERYTHING can be upcycled into something cool. While that may be true, the reality is many of those projects take extra time and sometimes extra supplies you may not have on hand.

This desire to repurpose items I got for free or at a deep discount led me to eventually pursue simplicity after being overwhelmed with all the upcycle project pieces that took over my garage.

While I still enjoy a good DIY project, I’ve significantly cut back on my project pieces and rarely pick things up off the side of the road anymore. Now that’s progress.

Getting rid of clutter

Frugal declutterers may be more prone to selling their clutter. While this can hold people back from getting things out of their house in some cases, it can be done well as long as you set deadlines.

In getting rid of the clutter, frugal declutterers will focus on how to save or make money. Frugal folks often become good at negotiating in order to make more money or get a better deal.

While donating everything would be simpler, when you’re practicing frugal decluttering and are on a tight budget, you’re willing to trade some time and inconvenience in an effort to get some money back.

Frugal declutterers don’t like clutter but also really don’t like wasting money. Figuring out creative ways to make do is also helpful.

Frugal decluttering

Frugal declutterers focus on the function of their items as they declutter. They may not get rid of as much as people who can easily replace items in their home.

They may keep more things just in case or to reuse it in a new way. When frugally decluttering you may also try to sell the items you are decluttering.

There is no right or wrong way to declutter. It is about figuring out what works best for you and your home and financial situation.

Choosing frugal decluttering may mean your process is a little less aggressive and a bit slower. It’s not the right answer for everyone, but it works well for me.

Want to keep up to date on the latest Simplicity Habit information? Sign up below and also receive the 8 Quick Decluttering Wins checklist!

Sharing is caring :)

18 Comments

  1. I really appreciate your article about Frugal Decluttering. And $20 IS a lot of money to many people! I think your article should be right beside any other article about decluttering. People need to be smart about what they get rid of and not just follow along blindly. I enjoy decluttering and can’t think of anything I have missed after it’s out of here!! And decluttering is an ongoing chore! Thanks again!

      1. One thing to remember is to carefully store extras in easily identifiable ways where they won’t get ruined. So all spare kitchen items can go in one box, with an inventory of contents. Same for clothing, which can be packed up by size and season. Too much of clutter is people holding onto things “just in case”, being unable to find them quickly and easily when needed, which results in either a mess as you hunt or buying another anyway.

  2. This really speaks to me. Unfortunately, I was/am a fabric hoarder. I have successfully been a fashion seamstress since I was only 15 years old. I have been making pillow cases for the homeless shelter that I volunteer at. This has helped me to reduce my fabric stash. The $20. rule is difficult for me since I have retired. That doesn’t mean that I don’t get ruthless and donate
    frequently. We really do need open space to function properly.

    1. Thanks for your comment, Linda. That’s wonderful that you are using your skills to help and declutter too!. I recently started destashing my fabric (I used to sew baby blanket sets). I got realistic about how much I would use and downsized from 5 bins to 2. I may decide to go to just 1. It was hard thinking about what I’d spent on it, but I don’t sew as much anymore so I wanted someone to have it who could use it. And you are totally right on needing open space to function.

    2. Fantastic article! I am in the midst of frugal decluttering, for I am one that need the cash. With a kid in college and another going soon, every penny counts! I have found our family struggle is clothing. By barter and trading, we have accumulated many pieces of clothing for t 4 of us, and I would keep the best pieces from my oldest for my youngest. This year I said no more! Our community has a clothing give away run by our school, and I have been downsizing our collection for a good cause. Feels so good to gain space, empty totes, and bless others at the same time!

  3. Loved your article. Thank you. Simple is my goal. After years of being a collector of way too many passions. I appreciate being respectful of everyone’s choices and options of how, when and where! Do what’s best for you and yours!

  4. Thank you so much for writing this. As someone who loves the idea of minimalism but really struggles to balance the reality of these concerns, it’s like a lightbulb went off! I always felt like a decluttering failure when trying to practically do these things, but now I realize that a lot of minimalism doesn’t really address those realities. And that it’s okay to not have to discard some of the systems that you know work for your situation. And even more valuable is how you talked about ways to do that with balance and practicality so that you don’t get stuck in the other extreme. Thank you, Thank you, Thank you!

  5. Thank you! This sounds just like me. I am – slowly – de-stashing as I have realized for a couple of years now that I am more of a wannabe-craftsperson than a proper one. I came from a line of hardworking craftspeople (hobby and/or livelihood). History weighs on my shoulders. I am more a books person. At my age I am becoming aware that I no longer have enough time or, more importantly, interest. I am just trying to make more space around me. I feel better already but still have quite a way to go.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *